Sat 25 Jul 2009
Health By GOP
Posted by USA / Carol under Balkers
[22] Comments
Forty some years ago, the Republican Party reorganized with the intent of reshaping public policy to reflect its conservative views. They developed a core group of “think tanks” such as the Heritage Foundation, to set goals, develop strategy and fund other +organizations to implement policy. They bought media outlets and began using the internet to take control of the message, reeducate and reshape the views of the ‘liberal’ American public and the “institutional strongholds of American liberalism: academia, Congress, the judiciary, executive branch agencies, religious institutions and philanthropy itself…actively promoting an anti-government, unregulated markets agenda”, as written by Sally Covington in an article,
- How Conservative Philanthropies and Think Tanks Transform US Policy
, published in the Covert Action Quarterly, in the winter of 1998. They funneled “$80 million to right-wing policy institutions… another $89 million supported conservative scholars and academic programs” and $27 million was spent “to recruit and train the next generation of right wing leaders.”
They also targeted federal anti-poverty programs contending “that poverty was the result of personal irresponsibility coupled with government programs that rewarded and encouraged it.”
They organized grass roots campaigns to put more Republicans into public office, first locally and then on a national level. Using highly questionable tactics – such as intimidation, fear tactics, religion, playing one group against another, spreading misinformation and using wedge issues, they succeeded in shifting the political leaning of the country from center to far right. Then they installed George W. Bush as President. Under Bush, conservatives succeeded beyond their wildest dreams in restructuring policy and changing our laws to favor the wealthy, corporations and Republican ideology.
Throughout history, Republicans have fought unions, workers’ rights, a living wage for workers, women’s voting rights, minimum wage increases to counter inflation, black civil rights and more recently, equal rights for women and gays. Their strategy has been simple: demonize, go on the attack and flood the media with disinformation and propaganda to stir up fear and mislead the public.
Over the past several decades, special interest groups have become very powerful. Their agenda has been to influence legislation and secure even greater economic power and influence for the wealthy, corporations and the health insurance and drug industries. They’ve virtually taken over in the US, in part by hiring former politicians who use their connections and expertise to lobby Congress on their behalf.
After many Republicans were voted out for incompetence last November, they adopted a strategy of obstructing all Democratic efforts to repair the damage done under the Bush administration. After the economic meltdown of Wall Street and the banking and housing industries that occurred before Bush left office, it became imperative for the U.S. to fix our hemorrhaging health care system. We won’t make a full economic recovery until and unless we do. Despite this, Republicans are furiously working to undermine health care reform. Their “strategy” is to bring down Obama and prevent Democratic efforts to create needed change. Though it may fatally wound our country, they believe it will give them a platform and a foot in the door to power in 2010.
Many Republicans (and some Democrats) have received millions in campaign contributions from health insurance companies. These same Republicans are responsible for circulating much of the misinformation used to incite fear and help the insurance industry maintain it’s stranglehold on our country and wallets.
One line of attack is to frighten the elderly about “death panels” that will deny care to frail seniors. Those who are poorly informed accept these false allegations and seem to do little credible research to determine facts. They’re further manipulated by far right organizations that front for health insurance companies. These are the people who are bused into Town Hall meetings to create chaos and prevent any real discussion that may correct misinformation and misunderstandings. They seem to take great pride in their role and the opportunity to speak out. But their outrage seems to reflect an undercurrent of racism in response to the election of a black President and a more liberal Democratic Party intent on change.
Republicans insist that a government option will result in rationed care. The reality is we already have rationed care through the insurance industry’s use of preexisting conditions, their refusal to approve necessary procedures and life-saving treatments and their policy of consistently raising the cost of health care premiums. Most of us pay for health care for many years and rarely use it, until we’re older. When patients do require on-going, extensive or catastrophic care, they often lose their coverage when they need it most or learn that their premiums have become so costly, they can no longer pay them.
Other tactics include painting nightmare scenarios about universal, government-run single-payer health care in other countries. Republicans tell shocking stories of the government making health care decisions for doctors and patients and controlling who lives or dies or receives crucial operations and procedures. They also claim that patients are unable to choose their own doctor, must wait for months to see their physician or years for heart surgery and other time-critical procedures.
According to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, profits rose 428% for the ten largest U.S. health insurance companies between 2000-2007—from 2.4 billion to 12.9 billion. Combined total compensation for CEOs at these companies was $118.6 million, or $11.9 million each, on average. This is 468 times more than the $25,434 income of the average American.
During this same period, the number of uninsured rose 19%, from 38.4 million to 45.7 million.
According to an article titled, Health Care Lobbyists vs. The People: The Final Showdown, written by Art Levine and published in the Huffington Post on June 24, 2009, Senator Charles Schumer (D-NY) stated that “health insurance premiums have skyrocketed, going up more than 87% over the past six years.” This article also indicated that the health insurance industry has spent a half-billion dollars over a decade to block meaningful health care reform. They refuse to cover many health care costs, but will willingly spend a half billion dollars on lobbying.
A study published in the August issue of the American Journal of Medicine, indicates that “medical problems contributed to nearly two-thirds (62.1%) of all bankruptcies and more than three-quarters (77.9%) of those had insurance.”
The U.S. Census Bureau estimates that “nearly 46 million Americans, or 18 percent of the population under the age of 65, were without health insurance in 2007”. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality used the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS) to estimate that nearly 54 million Americans, or 27% of the population under 65, were uninsured in the first-half of 2007.
My mother was a single parent who supported her family as a nurse for many years in California. Thirty years ago, she broke her back and had x-rays, but was told there were no broken bones. A year later, after developing serious back problems, more x-rays were taken that showed several broken vertebrae and nerve damage to the surrounding tissue. By that time, she was using a wheelchair. She eventually had surgery to fuse her back and this eventually allowed her to walk again. Throughout this ordeal, the insurance company consistently raised her premiums until she could no longer afford coverage. Despite working hard, saving and investing for many years, she was forced to use her retirement to pay medical bills. For the rest of her life, she lived on social security.
A few years ago, a friend of mine needed surgery. She was told she would die within five years without it. Her health insurance company refused to approve the surgery on three different occasions over a period of six months. Instead, they demanded that she meet this or that requirement, in the hope that she would fail. She didn’t — she met each requirement and the doctors moved forward and set a date for the surgery. Nevertheless, the insurance company refused to authorize or approve it until the day before the operation had been scheduled. She had to fight for six months to get them to do the right thing.
The insurance industry is currently spending $1.4 million a day on lobbying to influence the public and prevent real health care reform. They’ve had decades to change the inequities and develop better health coverage options for more people, but their primary concern has been putting more money into their own pockets and spending enormous sums to prevent people from having the coverage they’ve paid for, for many years and are entitled to use.
A single payer universal health care option will be much less expensive and provide quality care. It will also force the insurance companies to compete, lower their premiums, offer better quality care and stop using preexisting conditions and illness to deny people coverage. Those who don’t want a government option will be free to continue with their current health insurance provider.
Howard Dean, M.D., who was also the Chair of the Democratic Party from February of ’05 until January of ’09, has written a book I highly recommend, Howard Dean’s Prescription for Real Health Care Reform: How We Can Achieve Affordable Medical Care for Every American and Make Our Jobs Safer.
Most Americans are fed up with the greed that drives our politicians, government, corporations, banks and the drug and insurance industries. We want real change that benefits real people.
I hope others around the world with universal, single-payer government health care will share information about your experiences, the quality of your care and the cost. If we can get a dialogue going here in the U.S. based on facts, rather than insurance industry-driven fear mongering, perhaps those taken in by unscrupulous Republicans will recognize that we have much more to gain and far too much to lose, to continue indulging and feeding the greed of the insurance industry.
Welcome back Carol – that is a great summarization of the cynical and corrupt operation, also known as the GOP (Grand Old Party / Republicans)
I actually think it’s mostly just the principals and point people like Cheney, Rove and Limbaugh, that simply don’t care about the social carnage created when they assume power and start tilting the table sharply towards those already most enfranchised in America / ultra wealthy.
(You’d have to be asleep though, not to understand that is the underlying goal… ;^)
Most followers however, I think buy into the dogma about laissez-faire capitalism, deregulation and prosperity Trickling Down if you just slash the tax obligation of that ultra-wealthy segment.
But then those policies fail (Great Depression and now…), and majorities get on to the fact that it’s all propaganda to serve that ulterior motive of making the wealthy better off – everyone else, go fend for yourself…
It’s amazing both the R’s in Congress like Mitch McConnell and John Boehner, and the proven-wrong mouthpieces like Rush Limbaugh and Bill O’Reilly, whom just go right along pushing the same failed agenda. And equally amazing how anyone (about 20% of Americans really is all) still falls for it!
I’ve got to repost this from Pat’s Balk. If ever there was a Smoking Gun…
—
Cigna whistleblower Wendell Potter, details decades of U.S. health insurance industry corruption / massive dump-the-sick scheme.
Video and transcript is linked below – a simply shocking validation, of what most Americans already suspected;
PBS / Bill Moyers Journal
I came to Canada from Washington DC with my Canadian wife 35 years ago. That turned out to be the best move I ever made. I say this in all due respect to the US.
Sine I retired I have had some serious illnesses. Heart attack, by-pass surgery, and seven years ago, colon cancer.
My cancer surgery was done within two weeks of diagnosis and I didn’t need to spend a penny. Same situation with my heat trouble.
I’m over 70 now and I am on several medications. I pay $100. Canadian per year and a small dispensing fee $4.11. per for refills.
I shutter to think if I where still living in the US what my situation would be. Thank God for the Canadian health care system
To my follow Americans, wake up, you deserve better.
I had a bad, bad feeling when Reagan was elected. Like watching a train wreck from a long way away and not being able to do anything about it.
Your analysis of the history of our current situation is spot on. But I am afraid we may have passed a tipping point, and may not be able to get our country back from the clutches of the corporatocracy.
Very disturbing and ironic to see teabaggers at disrupted town meetings on healthcare shout about Obama being a fascist/socialist. Did they never read any history? They are the fascists. The ignorant listen to talk radio and tv bought and paid for by the right-wing corporatocracy, and shout down those people trying to have discussions on healthcare. Didn’t Hitler’s supporters start out by disrupting meetings and shouting down people trying to have civilized discussions?
When they took over, all discussions ended.
Welcome aboard Jim and juanita – good remarks both.
Thanks, Jim for sharing information about your experiences with Canada’s health care system. Most Americans, 77%, want a public option. It remains to be seen whether Obama will stand up and stop pacifying Republicans in the hope of bipartisanship, despite their clearly articulated goal of bringing Obama, Democrats and even the country, down, if that’s what it takes to prevent reform.
Juanita, I agree — this is an ongoing far right tactic, projecting their behavior and the labels that identify it (fascism, socialism) onto Democrats who are working to repair the damage done over the past 8 years.
The Republicans are not against the kind of socialism that channels the wealth, influence and power into the hands of the wealthiest Americans. Redirecting the wealth of the country is only described as socialism when it benefits the middle class and poor.
Thank you Carol for acknowledging my post and thank you Roy G for the welcome.
This addendum is something I should have included in my original post.
The psychological effect of not having to worry about how to pay the medical bills is a huge contribution to getting well.
The medical/health situation in itself is a major worry, but by adding the concern of money into the equation compounds the situation.
Part of getting well is the state of mind of the patient, and that little intangible is something most people don’t think about.
I hope and pray that America will catch up with the rest of the world and come up with a humanitarian health plan for all.
Totally agree Jim – nobody needs to be burdened with costs they can’t hope to pay for, when trying to get better. And just having the insurance when well, will be peace of mind for those flying without a net right now. Especially those with families they have no coverage for.
It’s quite incredible when you add it all up, just how extreme a hardship the U.S. Congress permits for it’s people in this regard. They (Republicans and some Democrats) killed Clinton’s reform in 1994 and may again this time, entirely because they are in the pocket of the corporate interests that keep funding their re-elections.
And of course, they already have their government insurance… ;^)
Have courage.
Glen Beck has lost many sponsors.
Other sponsors are thinking of abandoning the cable talk (OR IS THAT YELLING!!) shows?
Soft boycotts, phone calls, letters, comments to your grocer and retailer do COUNT !
Do it
I saw one of the many GOP-compliant media outlets yesterday, trumpet some stat about Beck’s ratings being up due to the publicity about the boycott of his sponsors.
Which introduces the question; how does that help you when dozens of advertisers won’t buy anymore on your show? You don’t just replace those with some unlimited supply of new clients. And somebody new will face the same pressure, to not advertise with a hatemonger & documented liar.
Which in turn raises the issue of whether the success of the Beck boycott, might be blueprinted to other Wingnut Media shows. Generally, they only take form after hate speech uttered by the host, not over political positions, even when outright lies.
But those outlets have taken false statements to new levels of propaganda, as documented daily by the excellent fact-check website
MediaMatters.org. More people are on to them than ever, which means those consumers might be willing to join boycotts of the advertisers of these programs, after some of the more blatant lunacy like the “birther” and “death panel” episodes. We shall see.
Let the People have free choice on how and if they want Health insurance! Get the Gov’t and the Libbyist out of the politics and Washington D.C. and all there employess of the federal and state level try there new Health care plan first. The gov’t has no business snse to run anything, much less and most especially Health Care. Yes, there needs to be changes but, we the people know better of it then a bunch of fat cat politicians that always know how to spend our money better, while all the while they do not even have to live in our world, and as soon as they need money, they tax us, print more money and give themselves a raise! No, to anymore Gov’t controls of any kind! We here in the United States are unlike any other country on Earth. We are a Constitutional Republic, we are not a Democracy! We the people do have the Freedom to control our gov’t and we must not give it up!
Well, I liked the site and thought there would be critical thinking involved, but I can see where this is going. As soon as there is any debate the opposition immediantly goes to name Calling! Thank you for time…Good Bye!
Laura that government=bad thinking, is the heart of Republicanism. It caused the banks to collapse last year because BushCo didn’t think they needed much regulation and oversight. And then Republicans had to spend $750 billion of our tax dollars to correct that mistake!
Since government is always bad, that leads to things like the BushCo attempt to privatize Social Security a few years ago, and put all our holdings in the stock market. Which would have wiped out the retirement money of many millions!
And did Bush’s idea to ‘return the money back to the people’ when he slashed taxes on the rich in 2001, create jobs and prosperity that we enjoy today?
Anybody STILL thinking ‘government is the problem’, I sure hope you can never be cancelled off your health insurance if you get very ill, or if you lose your job.
Welcome Laura. History shows that laissez-faire economy (no government involvement) has failed numerous times in America, causing stock market crashes and runs on banks that caused many bank and business failures. The government had to step in each time, with new controls to restore fiscal and social order. We just saw it again during the Bush years, and returning to the failed Reagan ideology of Hands-Off / Trickle-Down, is
not an option.
The objective is to strike a balance between appropriate regulation that protects our citizens from the ravages of unchecked capitalism – i.e., all the things we see now such as massive job losses, home foreclosures, no insurance to get proper medical care, runaway energy price spikes – and
new investment and innovation that drives economic growth.
Not only is it possible to accomplish, it must be accomplished. Total government control of the economy is socialism, and is a proven failure. Total lack of control is laissez-faire capitalism, and is likewise a proven failure. The answer lies in a proper balance. Europe has been practicing it for decades and is far ahead of the U.S. in this regard. (GOP’ers; if your media outlet never clued you in on it, they have plenty of free enterprise
in Europe. They also protect their people from the fallout of business cycle downturns and corporate irresponsibility & excess. It can be done.)
Here I go again… ;^)
Capitalism is like a nuclear reactor – control the burn and it throws off enormous yield. Fail to control the burn and it melts down.
I can see why you hate Fox so much – beats the pants off your preferred propaganda outlets daily (stats below from Neilson):
Live + Same Day Cable News Daily Ratings for September 17, 2009
P2+ Total Day
FNC – 1,586,000 viewers
CNN – 590,000 viewers
MSNBC –454,000 viewers
CNBC – 197,000 viewers
HLN – 374,000 viewers
P2+ Prime Time
FNC – 3,238,000viewers
CNN— 1,054,000 viewers
MSNBC –1,123,000 viewers
CNBC – 259,000 viewers
HLN – 813,000viewers
Seems my original post was deleted – not that I’m surprised. I’ll just summarize to point out Laura has you people pegged. No intelligent life here, no honesty, just the usual propaganda and talking points. Try facts – they’re much better than ad hominem attacks any day.
This site has a TOS GregorMandelbaum. Going by your unhinged postings this afternoon, I wouldn’t doubt you posted some kind of threat before. And I see where you make NO rebuttal to Carol’s point by point breakdown on GOP corruptions at top. Facts?! LOL!
1) But Gregor since you are convinced that the media is liberal propaganda except Fox News, all those other channels you list add together :-)
2) If you weren’t brainwashed by their lies and Republican lies (same thing), you might be willing to clikc on the Media Matters.org link in the Favored list. They give facts daily that bust Fox’s daily lies.
Raven,
Thank you for the reminder about Media Matters. Also, loved your counter-point to Gregor. It was intended to be tongue-in-cheek (?) but, you make an excellent point. It gives one pause for hope when you add to those numbers what Gregor probably considers the liberal-dominated network (CBS, NBC, ABC) news!
Juanita,
30 years ago I started studying German history and ended up, 20 years ago, with a Masters in 20th C. German History. I wanted to know why/how an industrial, relatively cosmopolitan nation could fall to the Nazis/Fascism. Then, like now, the Conservatives and Nationalist parties and industrialists thought they could use the fringe fascists to defeat the Socialists and Communists parties. I see the GOP and corporations doing the same with the fringe, extremists in this country today. The experience of unbridled extremism, Left or Right, is unhealthy for any country and in an economic crisis, for a population already primed on a fear-diet of terror threats and threats to the “fabric of family-values” these past 8 years, well, the parallels to Germany in the late 1920’s and early 1930’s is frightening indeed.
The train-wreck you fear may be coming and if the lessons learned by those who survived the 1920’s, the Great Depression, and World War 2 are forgotten, or misrepresented, (as the revisionists on Fox News and on Right-wing controlled AM radio will have one believe), then tragically we are doomed to repeat them.
I would suggest for your view to be held in any regard you might want to do some fact checking, while your point on the conservative take over of the GOP from Goldwater on is well taken to try as you do in one paragraph to hold the GOP accountable for all of the last century’s problems is disingenuous.
“Throughout history, Republicans have fought unions, workers’ rights, a living wage for workers, women’s voting rights, minimum wage increases to counter inflation, black civil rights and more recently, equal rights for women and gays.”
The problem here is use of the words “Throughout history”, this is a distortion of facts. It was Theodore Roosevelt, Republican, who lead the fight against child labor, enforced the anti-trust act, pushed for business regulation and passed the food protection act. It was Wilson, Democrat, who fought against womens voting rights and who segregated some federal government departments. If you think that special interests are a new problem I would suggest you read Roosevelt’s New Nationalism Speech from 1910 it could be reread by President Obama today and not seem out of place.
The Republican Party was once the home of Progressive thought in American from McKinley to Roosevelt to LaFollette. To think that all people of one party are evil is a simplification that defies logic. There are still Republicans that hold the principles of Roosevelt, not many most have been driven out by the concerted efforts of the conservatives but some of us hold on.
As for the health care debate I have lived in two countries that have had national health-care systems and was treated under both. The quality of the care in both England and Greece was as good as any in America, the wait time was minimal and the one emergency treatment(car accident) was exceptional in quality and speed of care. I’ve heard all the stories going round about delay in care and rationing but in 6 years of living in Europe I never saw or heard of treatment delays or rationing that seemed out of norm. For non emergency surgery you may wait for a schedule opening or a recovery bed but if your life was in danger you were treated. As for Fox or talk radio I would suggest that these people are selling a product, buyer beware.
Welcome to Balkingpoints lvrplfc – well done remarks.
You can toss Jack Kemp in there also, who had progressive views on homesteading public housing to create an ownership stake, which were never adopted by his party.
His hijacked party, perhaps. Whether the GOP as presently led can ever take the step it has to – that is, divorcing Ronald Reagan and a failed Trickle Down / Deregulation ideology – in order to win back working Americans is highly in doubt.
They have effectively gone backwards for most of the last 30 years while
a minority of Americans prospered. No amount of window dressing and demagoguery and talking points can alter that. Broadly shared economic opportunity is the only way.
The GOP instead shows a total inability to acknowledge wrong policy and adjust accordingly, and an extremism on most of it’s planks that keeps people out of the tent.
Many Americans think the term Progressive means of necessity liberal or ultra-liberal. To me it only means policy that effects progress – solve the problem don’t ignore it. And some GOP’ers have had it, Lincoln being
the most prominent of course.
And so it is now with the crossroad on national health insurance. Long overdue progress, vs. an untenable status quo. As fabled progressive Bill Clinton said to Bush I in the 1992 debates “We’ve tried it your way for 12 years. It hasn’t worked. We need to change”… ;^)